Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Who Are You Calling A Villain?!
"Who Are You Calling A Villain?!" is a completed original web novel that I recently dove into, and it was quite the experience! With its blend of comedy, drama, romance, and a dash of the supernatural, it certainly kept me entertained. The university setting and focus on couple growth were definitely appealing.
First Impressions
Right off the bat, I was drawn in by the premise. The idea of a calm protagonist navigating the complexities of university life while dealing with some seriously strange dreams piqued my interest. The promise of a "dog-like" love interest, rather than the typical overbearing ML, also had me curious.
What Works Well
The relationship between Su Zhiyan and Shen Nianjing is undoubtedly the heart of this story. I really enjoyed the focus on their individual ambitions and how their love didn't overshadow their independence. The dynamic between them is endearing; Su Zhiyan's elegant "black cat" persona perfectly complements Shen Nianjing's confused "golden retriever" energy. The humor shines through in their interactions, especially after they become a couple. Shen Nianjing's proactive displays of affection are a delightful contrast to Su Zhiyan's initial shyness. The story thrives on simple misunderstandings and the straightforward nature of the main character once he embraces his feelings. The slice-of-life elements are well-executed, making the university setting feel authentic.
Areas of Concern
While I enjoyed the fluff and the romance, the explanation behind the dreams felt a bit convoluted. The whole "we're in a novel" concept seemed out of place and not fully explored. It felt like a loose end that detracted slightly from the overall narrative.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Okay, let's talk about those dreams. Apparently, the ML dreams of the MC killing him, while the MC dreams of... well, let's just say more intimate scenarios. The explanation involves a scrapped novel and fanfiction, which, to be honest, left me scratching my head. It's a bizarre plot point that could have been executed better.
Final Verdict
Overall, "Who Are You Calling A Villain?!" is a lighthearted and enjoyable read, perfect for those seeking a fluffy romance with a dash of supernatural intrigue. While the dream explanation could use some work, the engaging characters and focus on a healthy relationship make it a worthwhile experience. I'd recommend it if you're in the mood for something sweet and not too heavy.
