Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on She Was Both Called God, as Well as Satan
"She Was Both Called God, as Well as Satan" is definitely a novel that sticks with you. With its blend of adventure, fantasy, mystery, and even a dash of sci-fi, it's quite the unique cocktail. The premise alone – an immortal being observing the rise and fall of civilizations – is enough to grab your attention.
First Impressions
Initially, I was drawn in by the sheer originality of the concept. The idea of an ancient human, the last of her kind, watching over a new race struggling with magic and their own evolution is fascinating. It felt like a grand-scale social experiment, viewed through the lens of someone who has seen it all before.
What Works Well
The exploration of immortality and its potential consequences is a major strength. The main character's detached perspective, her struggle to find meaning after eons of existence, is compelling. The novel also excels at portraying the cyclical nature of history, with the new races making similar mistakes to their predecessors. It really makes you think about humanity's trajectory and whether we're doomed to repeat the past. I particularly enjoyed how the story spans vast periods, with each arc focusing on different characters and conflicts, yet always tying back to the overarching theme of observation and the evolution of society. The author's ability to depict the MC's complex and sometimes contradictory thoughts is really well done. It felt like a genuine attempt to portray the mindset of someone who has lived for millions of years, teetering on the edge of sanity.
Areas of Concern
While the premise is strong, I can see why some readers felt the execution faltered in certain areas. Some plot points felt rushed, potentially hindering further story development. Several readers also pointed out inconsistencies and plot holes that detracted from their enjoyment. While I personally enjoyed the novel, there are a few instances of potentially triggering content, so reader discretion is advised.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers mentioned that the new humanity never really reflects on the main character, which is a shame, and that the story had too much focus on random side characters.
Final Verdict
Overall, "She Was Both Called God, as Well as Satan" is a thought-provoking and unique read. While it has its flaws, its originality and exploration of complex themes make it a worthwhile experience. If you're looking for something different, a story that will make you ponder the nature of existence and the fate of humanity, this might be the novel for you. I'd give it a solid 4 out of 5 stars.
