Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on I Was Reincarnated as a Creepy Fat Guy, Then Trained Myself Without Sleep. And Then, for Some Reason, the Heroines Start Approaching Me
Okay, let's dive into this title, which is quite a mouthful! "I Was Reincarnated as a Creepy Fat Guy, Then Trained Myself Without Sleep. And Then, for Some Reason, the Heroines Start Approaching Me" certainly grabs your attention. It promises a blend of comedy, romance, and a dramatic transformation, but does it deliver? Here's my take after considering what readers are saying.
First Impressions
The premise is undeniably intriguing. We have a reincarnation, a significant physical change, and the classic harem setup. The initial hook is there, playing on familiar tropes with a unique twist. You're immediately curious about how this "creepy fat guy" is going to turn his life around and attract the attention of multiple heroines.
What Works Well
Some readers have pointed out the positive aspects of the MC's character development and his relationships with his friends. It seems the author put effort into portraying a genuine camaraderie, which is always a plus in stories like these. The transformation journey, while potentially unrealistic in its speed, can be motivating for readers who enjoy seeing characters overcome adversity. Also, the story doesn't just revolve around the MC, and we get to see the lives of other characters.
Areas of Concern
However, there are some significant issues that keep this novel from reaching its full potential. For me, the writing quality and character motivations seem to be a recurring problem. Some find the characters to be flat and unconvincing, lacking believable reasons for their actions. The speed of the MC's physical transformation has also been called into question, with some readers finding it unrealistic. Also, some readers have felt that the characters are not true to what have been revealed before, and the plot is not very interesting.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Okay, here comes a spoiler!
Some readers have expressed discomfort with the MC's initial attitude towards women and his pursuit of one-night stands after his transformation. This aspect of the story has been described as misogynistic. The MC's behavior of being intimate to multiple girls while keeping them in the dark has also been criticized.
Final Verdict
Overall, "I Was Reincarnated as a Creepy Fat Guy..." is a mixed bag. While the premise is interesting and it has some redeeming qualities in its portrayal of friendship and character growth, the issues with writing quality, character motivations, and potentially problematic themes hold it back. If you're a die-hard fan of the genre and can overlook these flaws, you might find some enjoyment here. However, for more discerning readers, there are likely better options available.
