Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Don’t Pretend to be Good (Esports)
"Don't Pretend to be Good (Esports)" definitely scratched an itch for me. It's a fluffy, romance-heavy esports story that prioritizes the relationship between the MC and ML over intense gaming action. If you're seeking a strategic, deeply detailed esports narrative, this might not fully satisfy. However, if you're in the mood for a sweet, heartwarming BL with esports as a backdrop, then keep reading.
First Impressions
I went into this expecting a thrilling esports drama, but I quickly realized the focus was elsewhere. We have a protagonist who isn't quite who he seems, and the initial hook comes from the slow reveal of his true personality. The synopsis promises a devilish side, and while it takes a while to fully emerge, the anticipation kept me engaged. The "shy around my idol" trope is definitely present, which can be a bit frustrating, but it's also a key element of the story's charm.
What Works Well
The romance is undoubtedly the strongest aspect. The ML is a total green flag, supportive and understanding, and his family is equally welcoming. The MC's journey of finding a surrogate family with the ML and his relatives is genuinely touching, especially given his strained relationship with his own father. The story also excels at creating a supportive environment within the esports team, which adds another layer of warmth to the narrative. While the esports aspects are less detailed, the author focuses on the team dynamic and the MC's growth within that environment. I also appreciated the comedic undertones, which kept the story light and enjoyable.
Areas of Concern
I found myself wanting more of the MC's "shameless" personality to shine through. The initial pretense of being obedient and shy sometimes felt prolonged, and I was eager for him to fully embrace his true self. The esports elements could have been more fleshed out, especially for readers who enjoy detailed game descriptions and strategic plays. The villain felt somewhat underdeveloped and didn't add significant tension to the overall plot.
Final Verdict
Despite its shortcomings, "Don't Pretend to be Good (Esports)" is a delightful read if you're looking for a romance-focused BL with a lighthearted tone and a heartwarming found-family dynamic. It's not the most groundbreaking esports novel, but it delivers on its promise of a sweet and engaging love story with a confident protagonist at its core. I'd recommend it for anyone seeking a feel-good story with low-stakes drama and plenty of fluffy interactions.














