Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on My Extraordinary Achievement
"My Extraordinary Achievement" definitely grabbed my attention with its blend of action, comedy, romance, and supernatural elements all wrapped up in a school-life setting. The premise of a "fat to fit" protagonist with a system sounded like a fun ride, so I dove in with high hopes.
First Impressions
Initially, the humor landed well with me. The idea of a system rewarding the MC for getting rejected repeatedly, especially with something like "hand speed," is genuinely funny. The early chapters had a lighthearted feel, and I appreciated the focus on the system's influence rather than solely on the time travel aspect.
What Works Well
The strongest point, without a doubt, is the characters. The MC is quite likeable, and his motivations generally make sense. The female lead is also well-received, and many readers, myself included, found the romance to be refreshingly natural. I especially appreciated the emphasis on normal interactions rather than the typical over-the-top displays of strength or protection. The focus on the MC improving himself through hard work, rather than relying solely on copied material, is also a plus. It's also a chill novel, there is no drama and the rich young master type of guys are like gentle raindrops in the background, present but easily ignorable.
Areas of Concern
However, I can see where some readers might lose interest. The quest structure can become repetitive, with the same daily routines and jokes recycled. This repetition may lead to boredom, especially if the humor doesn't continue to land. Some also find that the system spreads the plotline all over the place. He will be a painter, sportsman, entertainer and losing weight all at the same time. You get the feeling that he is "seized by the system" instead of actually doing what he wants.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers mentioned the novel vilifies South Koreans.
Final Verdict
Overall, "My Extraordinary Achievement" has moments of genuine fun and a charming cast of characters. The natural romance is a definite highlight. However, the repetitive nature of the quests and potentially stale humor might make it a better fit for readers who enjoy lighthearted, slice-of-life stories with a focus on character interactions over a complex plot. If you're looking for a chill read with a likeable MC and a sweet romance, this might be worth checking out.
