Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Cultivating Immortality Starts with Planting Techniques
"Cultivating Immortality Starts with Planting Techniques" presents a unique premise: a protagonist who cultivates immortality through the seemingly mundane act of farming. The blend of xianxia and farming elements immediately grabbed my attention, promising a refreshing take on the genre. While the initial chapters held promise, my experience with the novel became increasingly mixed as the story progressed.
First Impressions
The first arc is undoubtedly the strongest. The MC's cautious nature and the focus on farming as a means of cultivation felt innovative. I enjoyed the early emphasis on using his "cheat" to enhance his agricultural endeavors. It created a sense of grounded progression, which is often missing in the power-fantasy driven xianxia genre.
What Works Well
The initial concept is undeniably appealing. The idea of a cultivator meticulously tending to crops, discovering rare herbs, and using his harvests to fuel his journey towards immortality is genuinely captivating. The early world-building, while familiar to xianxia enthusiasts, provided a solid foundation for the story.
Areas of Concern
Unfortunately, the novel seems to stumble as it moves forward. The farming aspect, the very core of the story, gradually fades into the background. Mentions of the protagonist's agricultural activities become increasingly infrequent, often relegated to brief explanations of power increases. This shift diminishes the unique charm that initially drew me in.
Furthermore, the protagonist's character undergoes a significant transformation that I found jarring. He evolves from a cautious and well-intentioned individual into someone who appears selfish and even ruthless. His actions, particularly his indifference towards the plight of weaker individuals and his handling of relationships, left me feeling disconnected from his journey.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Specific plot developments, such as the protagonist's takeover of a mountain and his subsequent disregard for the local population, are particularly problematic. His failure to protect those under his supposed care, coupled with his later actions against them, paints him in an unfavorable light. The swift and often off-screen deaths of characters and the resolution of subplots also contribute to a sense of narrative disarray.
Final Verdict
"Cultivating Immortality Starts with Planting Techniques" has a compelling core concept that ultimately loses its way. While the initial arc offers a refreshing blend of farming and xianxia elements, the subsequent shift in focus and the protagonist's character development detract from the overall experience. The novel's descent into more conventional xianxia tropes, coupled with narrative inconsistencies, makes it difficult to wholeheartedly recommend, despite its promising start.
