Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Fire Arrow? No, This Is a Rifle!!!
"Fire Arrow? No, This Is a Rifle!!!" certainly grabbed my attention with its quirky title and promise of a blend of fantasy and modern technology. After diving in and considering the experiences of other readers, here's my take on this ongoing web novel.
First Impressions
The initial setup definitely feels familiar. It treads the well-worn path of the exiled protagonist, a trope that's either a guilty pleasure or a major turn-off depending on your taste. The story introduces a protagonist who, despite possessing the powerful "World Library" skill, seems strangely passive about improving his situation initially. I found myself questioning this decision, as it felt like a missed opportunity for early character development. However, if you can get past that initial hurdle, there appears to be a more compelling narrative waiting.
What Works Well
One of the strongest aspects seems to be the protagonist's growth and the involvement of the supporting cast. Many readers have praised the way the MC earns his achievements and relies on his companions, creating a sense of teamwork and shared struggle. This is a welcome change from the often-seen "lone wolf" protagonist. I also appreciate the integration of modern technology into a fantasy setting. It’s not just a simple copy-paste; instead, it's adapted and twisted by magic, leading to unique and interesting developments. The characters are well-developed and the translation is praiseworthy.
Areas of Concern
While the initial premise is intriguing, some readers have pointed out issues with the plot's progression. The ease with which the protagonist introduces advanced technology, like steam engines and firearms, raises questions about the story's internal logic. This rapid advancement might strain the suspension of disbelief for some readers. Also, the character development after the initial chapters seems to decline.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Several reviews contain spoilers regarding the protagonist's skill usage and the introduction of modern technology. Be cautious when reading discussions about these elements.
Final Verdict
"Fire Arrow? No, This Is a Rifle!!!" is a mixed bag. It has moments of brilliance, particularly in its character development and the integration of technology and magic. However, it also suffers from familiar tropes and questionable plot decisions. If you're a fan of the "exiled protagonist" trope and enjoy seeing modern technology shake up a fantasy world, this might be worth a read. Just be prepared for some potentially frustrating plot conveniences along the way. I'd give it a cautious recommendation, leaning towards a 3/5.
