Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Even If I’m Reborn as a Cute Dragon Girl, I Will Still Make a Harem
This web novel… it's certainly something. "Even If I’m Reborn as a Cute Dragon Girl, I Will Still Make a Harem" is a wild ride that seems to divide readers sharply. I went in knowing it was tagged as comedy, ecchi, and harem, but even then, I wasn't quite prepared for what I found.
First Impressions
Initially, I was charmed. The premise is ridiculous, and the early chapters focusing on the dragon's antics had a certain appeal. The main character's chuunibyou tendencies, while a bit much at times, were also amusing in small doses. However, as I delved deeper, I started to see why so many readers have mixed feelings.
What Works Well
The humor, when it lands, is genuinely funny. Some readers praise the series for being a lighthearted escape, a "pain relief" from more serious novels. The interactions between the dragons in the first volume were particularly well-received, described as sweet and enjoyable. The translator also deserves kudos; several readers specifically mentioned the translation quality as a strong point, even if the source material presented some challenges. The world-building, a blend of Japanese and Chinese elements, also seems to work for some, creating a unique and interesting setting.
Areas of Concern
The biggest issue, and the one that comes up repeatedly, is the intelligence level – or lack thereof – of many of the characters. Several readers found the characters too stupid to be enjoyable, particularly after the MC leaves the dragon's home. The introduction of certain supporting characters, like Carol, seems to be a major turning point for many, with some even suggesting skipping entire story arcs to avoid them. The plot progression is also incredibly slow, which can be frustrating. And the MC, despite being overpowered, often makes questionable decisions that undermine their supposed intelligence.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Several reviews mention the "auction arc" and the character Carol as being particularly problematic. Apparently, Carol's introduction leads to a series of increasingly ridiculous events, including getting scammed and captured, which many readers found nonsensical and irritating. Some suggest that the second volume, in general, is best skipped entirely.
Final Verdict
"Even If I’m Reborn as a Cute Dragon Girl, I Will Still Make a Harem" is a novel that demands a specific kind of reader. If you're looking for a serious, plot-driven story with well-developed characters, this probably isn't it. However, if you're in the mood for some mindless, over-the-top comedy and don't mind a healthy dose of absurdity, you might find something to enjoy here. Just be prepared for some potentially frustrating plot developments and characters along the way. Personally, I'm on the fence. The initial charm wore off for me, but I can see the appeal for those who appreciate this particular brand of humor.
