Aren’t You Just Going to Throw It Away Anyway?

どうせ捨ててしまうんでしょう？ · Original Japanese title

Also known as: Why would you throw it away anyway?, どうせ捨ててしまうんでしょう？

By suzumiya, 鈴宮(すずみや)

★★★★★ 3.9 37 ratings

Completed japanese Web Novel

Our review

Reviewed by Kana

Who it's for, and whether it holds up.

Author profile

My Thoughts on Aren’t You Just Going to Throw It Away Anyway?

First Impressions

"Aren’t You Just Going to Throw It Away Anyway?" immediately caught my eye with its intriguing title. The premise of a romance blossoming alongside a character's journey to overcome their insecurities is definitely something I'm drawn to. Plus, the "oneshot" tag gave me hope for a quick, satisfying read. I went in expecting a sweet, if perhaps somewhat condensed, story.

What Works Well

The strongest point of this novel, in my opinion, is how it tackles the female lead's inferiority complex. It's not just a superficial flaw; the male lead actively helps her confront it and find the courage to pursue her passions. This support system felt genuine and heartwarming, making their relationship more meaningful. I appreciated that the romance didn't feel forced or rushed, despite the story's short length. The development, even at a faster pace, felt believable and earned. The presence of a "green tea" cousin adds a layer of conflict that's satisfyingly resolved, and it's always nice to see the protagonist stand up for themselves with a little help from their friends (or love interests!).

Areas of Concern

Because it's a oneshot, the pacing is understandably quick. While I personally didn't find it detrimental to my enjoyment, some readers might find it a bit too fast-paced, potentially missing out on deeper character development or world-building that a longer story could offer. The focus is definitely on the romance and overcoming the MC's insecurities, so if you're looking for a complex plot or intricate world, this might not be the story for you.

Final Verdict

Overall, "Aren’t You Just Going to Throw It Away Anyway?" is a delightful, feel-good story perfect for a quick and satisfying read. If you enjoy romances where characters support each other's growth and overcome obstacles together, then I highly recommend giving this one a try. Just be aware that it's a short and sweet experience, so manage your expectations accordingly.

Synopsis

I, Willow Radgem, and Emuria Radgem are cousins. Emuria is the daughter of my father’s older brother and a marquess. In contrast, I am the daughter of a earl, belonging to a lower rank. Since our fathers are brothers and we are the same age, we were raised like sisters. We frequently visited each other’s mansions, played, studied, and went out together. Now that we attend the academy in the capital, we even share the same townhouse. Because of these circumstances, Emuria is both my cousin and my best friend. For a noblewoman with few playmates, having such a person was very much appreciated. But there is one troublesome habit she has. That is, she often imitates me. From dresses to hairstyles, makeup, hair ornaments, school bags, and even ribbons on our uniforms – everything was imitated. Even the beautifully delicate glass fountain pen, the leather notebook, and the secretly carried gold pocket watch were all copied. However, she does it without any ill intentions. On the contrary, she doesn’t even realize she’s imitating; she thinks she found and acquired them because she liked them. Will she also like the man who i will like?

Aren’t You Just Going to Throw It Away Anyway?

Our review