Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Brother, You Smell Good
"Brother, You Smell Good" is a charming and sweet read that really grabbed my attention. With a 4.5/5 rating, I knew I was in for something enjoyable, and I wasn't disappointed. It's a blend of comedy, romance, school life, and slice of life, and it hits those notes perfectly.
First Impressions
Right off the bat, I was drawn in by the premise of a reborn MC trying to avoid his past mistakes and build a better life with his lover. The idea of a second chance, especially when it comes to love, is always appealing. The story felt lighthearted and easy to dive into, promising a fluffy and heartwarming experience.
What Works Well
What I really appreciated was the MC's growth. He acknowledges his past flaws and actively works to improve himself, which is refreshing to see. The relationship between the MC and ML is adorable, even with the initial hurdle of the ML's homophobia. I found the way the author tackled this sensitive topic to be well-done, exploring the reasons behind the ML's prejudice and showing his gradual acceptance. The humor sprinkled throughout the story is also a highlight, especially the ML's cluelessness and the awkward situations it creates. Many readers praised the "golden retriever" personality of the ML, and I have to agree—he's incredibly endearing. I especially loved how supportive both of their families were, and the playful dynamic between the MC and ML's friends.
Areas of Concern
While I thoroughly enjoyed the novel, I can see why some might find the ML's initial homophobia uncomfortable. Though it's handled with care, it's still a sensitive topic that could be triggering for some readers. Also, the ending of the main story felt a bit abrupt, but thankfully, the extras provided a satisfying conclusion and explored various "what if" scenarios.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
If you haven't read the novel, be warned, the following contains spoilers!
One of the most touching moments was seeing the ML's perspective after the MC's death in their first life. It added a layer of depth and emotion to their relationship, making their second chance even more meaningful. And I was so glad to see that the ML eventually regained his memories in the extras!
Final Verdict
Overall, "Brother, You Smell Good" is a delightful and heartwarming story that I highly recommend. It's a perfect pick-me-up for anyone looking for a sweet, fluffy, and ultimately satisfying read. The characters are lovable, the plot is engaging, and the overall vibe is just incredibly wholesome. Despite a few minor drawbacks, it's a novel that will leave you with a smile on your face.
