Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on The Struggle of Returning to The Other World
First Impressions
"The Struggle of Returning to The Other World" presents an interesting twist on the isekai genre. Instead of focusing on a character gaining power, it explores the aftermath of being a chosen one. I was immediately intrigued by the premise of an ex-saint trying to live a normal life after returning to a world she once saved. It felt like a breath of fresh air in a genre often saturated with overpowered protagonists.
What Works Well
What I found most compelling was the protagonist, Haruka. Her struggle to adapt to a life without the privileges and responsibilities of sainthood felt very relatable. The story excels in portraying the mundane aspects of her new life, like working at a restaurant and delivering bentos. The slow-burn pacing allows for detailed world-building and character development, creating a cozy and immersive experience. I also appreciated the realistic portrayal of unrequited love. Haruka's lingering feelings for Noel, and her attempts to move on, added a layer of emotional depth to the story. I was glad to see that she's not depicted as desperately chasing after him, but rather trying to navigate her feelings in a mature way.
Areas of Concern
Despite the novel's strengths, I can see why some readers might find it slow or frustrating. The plot progression is gradual, and those looking for action or immediate conflict might be disappointed. The focus on Haruka's internal struggles and daily life can feel like a diary at times, potentially lacking the emotional connection needed to fully engage with the characters. Additionally, the unrequited love aspect, while realistic, might annoy some readers who prefer a more straightforward romance. Some might also find the main character to be too passive and not have enough drive.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers expressed frustration with the romantic development, specifically the lack of interaction between Haruka and Noel. Haruka's avoidance of her knight and some of her decisions were also criticized.
Final Verdict
Overall, "The Struggle of Returning to The Other World" is a unique and engaging story that offers a refreshing perspective on the isekai genre. While the slow pace and focus on slice-of-life elements may not appeal to everyone, I found the protagonist's struggles and the detailed world-building to be quite compelling. If you enjoy character-driven stories with a touch of fantasy and a realistic portrayal of emotions, this novel is definitely worth checking out.
