Naze ka S-kyuu Bijo-tachi no Wadai ni Ore ga Agaru ken

Naze ka S-kyuu Bijo-tachi no Wadai ni Ore ga Agaru ken

なぜかS級美女達の話題に俺があがる件 / なぜかS級美女達の話題に俺があがる件 (角川スニーカー文庫) (脇岡こなつ) / 何故かS級美女達の話題に俺がよくあがるようになった件〜身に覚えがない捏造はやめてください〜 · Original Japanese title

Also known as: For some reason, I'm a topic of conversation between S-rank beauties (LN), The Issue of Why I’m Frequently Mentioned in Conversations Among S-Class Beauties ~Please Stop Fabricating Things I Have No Memory Of~, なぜかS級美女達の話題に俺があがる件, なぜかS級美女達の話題に俺があがる件 (角川スニーカー文庫) (脇岡こなつ), 何故かS級美女達の話題に俺がよくあがるようになった件〜身に覚えがない捏造はやめてください〜

3.3 77 ratings
japanese Light Novel

Our review

Reviewed by Kana

Who it's for, and whether it holds up.

Author profile

The premise is exactly what the title describes: an ordinary guy becomes inexplicably interesting to a cluster of beautiful classmates. Standard harem school-rom-com territory, nothing more promised.

The light novel adaptation apparently diverges from the web novel by giving each girl her own volume, building out individual storylines for characters like Sara, Yuna, and Rin rather than juggling them simultaneously. That structural choice is the most interesting thing about the series. It's at least an attempt at doing character work rather than spinning plates.

The problems are significant. Translation quality is a recurring complaint, with missing sections and awkward phrasing making it hard to track what's actually happening. That's a fundamental issue with any translated web novel, but it's worse here than average based on what readers report. The other issue is the protagonist himself. His denseness in the face of obvious signals isn't played as charming obliviousness, it stretches past what the comedy format can support and starts to make him seem less like a character and more like a device.

At 3.3 this is below-average even for its genre. The individual-girl-focused structure has promise, and if the translation improves the experience might too. Right now the execution doesn't match the concept. Worth checking back on if later volumes tighten things up, but not a priority read in its current state.

Synopsis

“Actually, I had a life-changing encounter that will greatly affect my future.” Sara Himekawa, Rin Kohinata, and Yumena Takamori are high school girls known as the ‘S-class beauties.’ While the class is filled with envy-inducing love stories, there’s Haruya Akasaki, the quietest guy in class. In fact, the guy they’re talking about is Haruya Akasaki!! A romantic school harem comedy about a shy boy and the ‘S-class beauties’ has begun.”

Details

Language
japanese
Type
Light Novel
Status
Ongoing
Chapters
4 volumes
Original Publisher
Unknown

Genres & tags

Browse all reviews →