Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on I Was Made the Disciple of a Yandere Girl, But
"I Was Made the Disciple of a Yandere Girl, But" is a novel that certainly provokes a range of reactions. With a solid 4/5 rating, it's clear many readers find it enjoyable, but the specific aspects that click, and those that don't, seem to vary quite a bit. I dove in expecting a dark, intensely yandere-focused story, and my experience was a bit more nuanced than that.
First Impressions
Initially, I was drawn in by the premise. A protagonist suddenly thrust into a world with a mentor who's a bit too attached? Sounds like a recipe for thrilling, slightly unhinged fun. The early chapters set a decent pace, introducing the characters and the world without overwhelming me with exposition. I found myself curious to see how the "yandere" aspect would play out.
What Works Well
The dynamic between the MC and his mentor, Arisa, is definitely a strong point. The story seems to excel at depicting the gradual shift in her character, and how her obsession develops over time. The plot twists, especially later in the story, kept me engaged and eager to see what would happen next. The author does a good job foreshadowing future events.
Areas of Concern
I can see why some readers feel the "romance" tag might be misleading. The relationship between the characters seems to lean more towards obsession than genuine romance, especially as the story progresses. The humor is also a bit lacking.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers have pointed out that the introduction of a second female lead complicates the yandere dynamic. Apparently, instead of triggering jealousy, Arisa seems relatively accepting, which some found inconsistent with the yandere archetype. There's also a scene where Arisa ties up the MC, which some readers felt was forced and out of character.
Final Verdict
Overall, "I Was Made the Disciple of a Yandere Girl, But" is an interesting novel with a unique premise and engaging plot twists. While it might not fully deliver on the intense yandere experience some readers are looking for, it offers a compelling story with well-developed characters and a dark, obsessive edge. If you're open to a story that blends yandere elements with harem and isekai tropes, and don't mind a potentially misleading romance tag, this might be worth a read. I would recommend this to people who are looking to get into dark novels as the start is very easy to read.
