Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on I Was a Sword When I Reincarnated (WN)
Okay, let's dive into "I Was a Sword When I Reincarnated." This web novel has been on my radar for a while, and after looking at what readers are saying, I've got a pretty good feel for it. It seems like a fun, if somewhat uneven, ride.
First Impressions
The initial chapters seem to be a sticking point for many. Several readers found them boring, describing them as a simple grind of skill acquisition. I can see how a sword just floating around, leveling up, might not grab everyone. It sounds like a bit of a slow burn, but I also see where others were happy to watch the MC explore and get stronger.
What Works Well
The real turning point, it seems, is when the sword meets Fran, the catgirl wielder. This is where the story really takes off. I'm seeing a lot of love for Fran – she's described as cute, determined, and a total badass. The dynamic between the sword (Master/Shisho) and Fran is repeatedly praised, with many appreciating the paternal-filial relationship. It's refreshing to see an isekai that doesn't devolve into a harem situation. The world-building, while not groundbreaking, is solid, and the action sequences are apparently well-balanced with slice-of-life elements. Also, the way the story uses tropes and cliches is interesting, with some being played straight and others being subverted.
Areas of Concern
Some readers felt the story becomes cliche after a while, with the sword's skill-stealing ability being a particular point of contention. The pacing also seems to be an issue, with some feeling that character development is rushed. There's also the issue of translation quality, which has apparently fluctuated over time, although that appears to be resolved.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
I'm seeing some mentions of spoilers, particularly regarding the MC's powers and Fran's character development. So, be warned if you're going in blind!
Final Verdict
Overall, "I Was a Sword When I Reincarnated" sounds like a worthwhile read, especially if you enjoy shounen adventures with a slice-of-life twist. While the beginning might be a bit slow, the relationship between the sword and Fran seems to be the heart of the story, and I'm definitely intrigued enough to give it a try. Just be aware of the potential for some generic isekai tropes and the initial slow pacing. I'm going in with moderately high expectations, hoping for a fun and heartwarming adventure.
