Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Cultivation: Being Immortal
"Cultivation: Being Immortal" presents an interesting premise: a protagonist with potentially limitless lifespan navigating the cultivation world and beyond. However, my journey through the available chapters has been a bit of a mixed bag, leaving me with both anticipation and reservations.
First Impressions
Initially, the concept grabbed my attention. The idea of a cultivator living through ages, experiencing historical events, and potentially even venturing into space holds immense appeal. The early chapters seem to focus on character interactions, which is a strong point that I found engaging.
What Works Well
The character development, particularly in the first half of the story, seems to be a highlight. I appreciated the gradual growth of the MC, witnessing his journey alongside characters who mature and change significantly over time. The villains in the early stages also provide a compelling and unique challenge. The plot is unique and has an interesting premise.
Areas of Concern
My biggest hesitation revolves around the protagonist's initial characterization. He comes across as somewhat passive and lacking ambition. While some might find his "easy-going" nature appealing, I hoped to see him embrace the opportunities of his long lifespan more fully, perhaps by mastering various cultivation paths. The plot also seems to decline in the later half, losing its original focus.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers have expressed frustration with the MC's decisions regarding his family. The choice to conceal his identity, even after hundreds of years, struck me as a frustrating plot point. This may be a make-or-break element for readers who prioritize family dynamics and character consistency.
Final Verdict
"Cultivation: Being Immortal" has the potential to be a captivating read, especially for those familiar with cultivation stories. The character interactions, early plot, and unique time-spanning premise are definite strengths. However, the slow pace, protagonist's initial characterization, and some questionable plot decisions in the later half give me pause. Overall, I would give it a cautious recommendation, especially if you are willing to persevere through the initial chapters and enjoy a long, character-driven narrative.
