Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on But Shixiong Doesn’t Want To Be A Villain!
"But Shixiong Doesn’t Want To Be A Villain!" is a xianxia transmigration novel that definitely took me for a ride. It's a story with a lot of mystery, and while I appreciated certain aspects, I also found some elements frustrating.
First Impressions
Going in, I was intrigued by the synopsis – a protagonist trying to avoid a villainous fate. However, I quickly realized that the story is more complex than it initially lets on. The MC transmigrates into a novel as a villainous character and is determined to avoid the ML, but the plot thickens as he uncovers more about the world and his role in it.
What Works Well
The central mystery is definitely a strong point. I found myself wanting to piece together the puzzle alongside the MC. The relationship between the MC and his shidi and master was also enjoyable, adding a layer of warmth to the story. Also, when the ML disguised himself, their interactions were very cute. The author does a great job of writing the ML's shameless teasing and the MC's shy reactions.
Areas of Concern
One of my biggest issues was the pacing and plot execution. The story felt disjointed at times, with plot points appearing suddenly. The transitions between plot points were poorly executed and could feel like whiplash. I also felt like the world-building was lacking. Magic items and factions are introduced without much background, making it hard to fully invest in the world.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
A major point of contention is the use of amnesia. It pops up frequently, and while some readers might be okay with it, I found it overused and detrimental to character development. The MC's constant memory loss made it difficult to connect with him and understand his motivations. Furthermore, the ML deceiving the MC with lies was uncomfortable. The MC's reaction to finding out the ML's true identity felt overdramatic.
Final Verdict
Overall, "But Shixiong Doesn’t Want To Be A Villain!" is a mixed bag. The plot can be engaging, but the execution is lacking. If you enjoy complicated stories with morally grey characters and don't mind a heavy dose of amnesia, you might find something to enjoy here. However, be prepared for a bumpy ride with some frustrating plot elements along the way. I'd give it a 3 out of 5 stars.
