Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on The Sword Immortal was My Ex-Boyfriend
This novel, "The Sword Immortal Was My Ex-Boyfriend," has been quite the ride, and I'm eager to share my thoughts. It's a completed original work that blends drama, romance, and xianxia elements, and while it has a strong overall rating, there are definitely some nuances to unpack.
First Impressions
The synopsis is... well, misleading. That's the first thing I need to address. It paints a picture of potential scum-baggery, but from what I've gathered, it's more a story of monumental misunderstandings and miscommunication leading to heartache and, eventually, second chances. The double transmigration element adds a unique layer, and the promise of character growth definitely piqued my interest.
What Works Well
The core strength of this novel lies in its characters. Both the female lead (FL) and male lead (ML) undergo significant development, learning from their past mistakes in their 21st-century lives. The ML's journey, in particular, seems compelling. He starts as someone with deep-seated insecurities and communication issues but grows into a more confident and self-assured individual. The FL also learns to communicate better and not jump to conclusions.
The chemistry between the leads is also something to look forward to, as they try to navigate their past and build a healthier relationship in this new life. The novel is also filled with life lessons, with one reader even sharing some quotes they found particularly impactful. I also appreciate that the FL isn't a perfect "holy maiden" character. She has flaws, makes mistakes, and isn't afraid to stand up for herself. This makes her feel more realistic and relatable.
Areas of Concern
While many enjoyed the plot, one reader noted issues with the female lead's actions, particularly regarding a disciple and perceived "reverse harem" elements. I can see how those actions could be off-putting to some readers. Another reader noted that the MTL was not worth reading and that they would reread it once it was properly translated.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Okay, here's where things get a little spoilery, so proceed with caution! Some reviews touched on the specifics of the FL and ML's past relationship. Apparently, a major turning point involves the FL hiring a fake boyfriend to get back at the ML, which leads to a messy breakup. The ML also sacrifices a lot to save the FL, even after everything. These details definitely add layers of complexity to their relationship and make their journey towards reconciliation all the more compelling.
Final Verdict
Despite some potential pitfalls and the misleading synopsis, "The Sword Immortal Was My Ex-Boyfriend" sounds like a worthwhile read, especially if you enjoy stories with flawed characters, significant growth, and a focus on overcoming past mistakes. If you are looking for a funny and engaging story, this might be the one for you! I'd recommend waiting for a good translation before diving in to fully appreciate the story's nuances.
