Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting
"Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting" hooked me from the premise. The idea of a protagonist cycling through roles as criminal, investigator, and victim in detailed, dark crime simulations? I was immediately intrigued. After diving in, I found a story that, while not without its flaws, delivers a truly compelling and often disturbing experience.
First Impressions
The initial arc is strong, drawing you into the protagonist's unfeeling and indifferent nature, which I found oddly appealing. The author does a fantastic job handling the complex emotions of everyone involved, from the murderers to the victims and the investigators. I was immediately invested in seeing where the story would go.
What Works Well
The psychological depth of the characters is a definite highlight. Delving into the minds of criminals, investigators, and victims, and seeing how the MC navigates these roles, is fascinating. The cases themselves are detailed and distinct, and the livestream aspect, while potentially disruptive, ultimately adds a layer of realism and distance that I appreciated given the dark subject matter. I also appreciate that the novel doesn't glorify criminal acts; there's always a price to be paid, which adds a layer of moral complexity. It's rare to find a thriller with a female protagonist, no romance, and such immersive storytelling. The emotional richness and the way the characters are written kept me engaged despite the heavy themes.
Areas of Concern
The constant barrage of comments from the in-story livestream audience can be annoying and disruptive. While the author likely intended this to add realism, it can sometimes detract from the main story, forcing me to skip large sections of text. It's a minor gripe, but it does impact the overall reading experience. Some minor details can be watery, and the logic of events can be stretched to the breaking point.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
One reader mentioned tearing up at the end of the first arc, expecting a bad ending. The father's guilt and the ultimate outcome are certainly emotionally impactful.
Final Verdict
Despite some minor flaws, "Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting" is a thrilling and psychologically engaging novel that I highly recommend. Be warned, though: it gets dark. Very dark. But if you're looking for a unique and immersive thriller that explores the depths of the human psyche, this is definitely worth a read. Just maybe have a slice-of-life novel on hand to cleanse your palate afterward!