Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on I’m an Old Man but Also a Saint?
Alright, let's dive into "I’m an Old Man but Also a Saint?". I went in with a healthy dose of curiosity, and I came out feeling… well, a little conflicted, but ultimately entertained. This novel is definitely a unique experience, blending adventure, comedy, and fantasy with a mature romance that might tickle your fancy if you're into the yaoi genre.
First Impressions
The initial hook is intriguing: an "old man" who's also a saint. However, the "old man" part is where things get a little… interesting. The protagonist is actually in his early forties, which, let's be honest, isn't exactly geriatric. This creates a bit of a disconnect. I was initially expecting someone a bit more seasoned, perhaps closer to the 70-90 range, and the initial description definitely threw me off.
What Works Well
Despite my initial reservations, I found myself drawn to the protagonist’s internal monologue. He's incredibly self-deprecating and riddled with self-doubt, which, while potentially annoying to some, adds a layer of relatable vulnerability. The humor is definitely present, and the "current day" way of speaking from the MC, juxtaposed against the European-esque fantasy setting, creates a fun, almost anachronistic vibe.
The romance elements are also a strong point, especially if you enjoy devoted love interests. The story seems to focus on building deep connections, which is a refreshing change of pace from some of the more fast-paced narratives out there.
Areas of Concern
The biggest hurdle for me was definitely the "old man" persona of the protagonist. While some might interpret it as a cultural nuance or a reflection of his isolated lifestyle, I still felt like it could have been executed better. It's a core element of the premise, and I think making him a bit older would have strengthened the narrative significantly.
Final Verdict
"I’m an Old Man but Also a Saint?" is an oddball story that, despite its quirks, managed to win me over. It's not without its flaws, and the "old man" thing might be a stumbling block for some. However, if you can look past that, you'll find a genuinely entertaining story with a unique protagonist, a charming romance, and plenty of laughs along the way. I'd say give it a shot – you might be pleasantly surprised.
