Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Ikemen ni Tenseishita kedo, Cheat ha Dekimasenseshita
This web novel, with its somewhat unwieldy title, promised a comedic take on the otome isekai genre. After diving in and considering the experiences of others, I've come to a nuanced conclusion. It's a story with definite strengths, but also a few quirks that might not appeal to everyone.
First Impressions
Initially, I found the premise intriguing. A reincarnated protagonist, handsome but without any real cheat abilities, blundering his way through an otome game world he doesn't even know exists? Sounds like a recipe for some good laughs. Some readers, however, found the early chapters rough, citing cringeworthy humor and unlikeable character traits. I can see where they're coming from. The initial tone is a bit…much.
What Works Well
Once past the initial hurdles, the story does find its footing. Many readers praised the comedic aspects, finding the MC's obliviousness genuinely funny. I particularly enjoyed the multi-POV approach, which gives glimpses into the machinations of other reincarnated individuals, like the villainess trying to avoid her doom and the heroine aiming for a reverse harem. The romance, surprisingly, seems to be a strong point for many, with a focus on a dedicated relationship rather than a harem situation. The MC, despite his flaws, is generally considered a kind, bright, and cheerful person, which is refreshing. Several readers noted that the world-building is well-thought-out and keeps them engaged.
Areas of Concern
The MC's intelligence, or lack thereof, seems to be a sticking point for some. While some find his cluelessness endearing or a refreshing change from the hyper-competent protagonists often found in isekai, others find him frustratingly dense. Some found the writing quality dipped later in the story, and the plot meanders.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Several reviews mention a potentially triggering NTR/mind-control arc later in the story, which led some readers to drop the novel. There are also concerns about character development, particularly with the MC and the reincarnated duke's daughter. Some felt that the duke's daughter, despite her knowledge and authority, makes bafflingly passive choices. The antagonist's motivations were also criticized as being convoluted and lacking sufficient depth.
Final Verdict
Ikemen ni Tenseishita kedo, Cheat ha Dekimasenseshita is a bit of a mixed bag. If you're looking for a lighthearted, comedic take on the otome isekai genre with a focus on romance and don't mind a somewhat dense protagonist, this might be worth a try. However, be aware of the potential for early cringe, inconsistent writing, and potentially problematic plot developments later on. Approach with cautious optimism, and maybe read a few more chapters than usual before making a final decision.
