Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on I Forged Them in Darkness, and They Buried Me in It
"I Forged Them in Darkness, and They Buried Me in It" is a novel that certainly left me with mixed feelings. The premise alone is enough to pique anyone's interest: a cultivator intentionally grooming women destined to betray him across lifetimes? That's the kind of high-concept idea I'm always on the lookout for. However, the execution seems to be where things get a bit dicey.
First Impressions
Initially, I was drawn in by the mystery surrounding the protagonist and how he ended up in his current broken state. The flashbacks and glimpses into his past lives, and relationships with these powerful women were intriguing. I was eager to see how the author would weave together the different timelines and reveal the protagonist's motivations.
What Works Well
The core concept is undoubtedly the strongest point. The idea of a protagonist actively shaping his own downfall is a fascinating twist on the typical cultivation narrative. There are glimpses of brilliance in the early arcs, particularly in exploring the initial dynamics between the protagonist and the heroines. Some of the backstories have potential, and the mystery of the protagonist's past is compelling.
Areas of Concern
Unfortunately, it seems the novel struggles with pacing and consistency. The narrative jumps between timelines feel jarring, and I heard that some arcs drag on while others are rushed. This makes it difficult to get invested in any single storyline or character. The protagonist's detached personality is also a point of contention. While a calm protagonist can be appealing, it seems his passivity can make him feel more like a plot device than a fully realized character. I've also heard that the ending is abrupt and unsatisfying, leaving many plot threads unresolved.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
One of the reviews mentions a plot point involving a witch and a priest in one of the flashbacks, which might not appeal to all readers of cultivation novels. If you're strictly looking for traditional cultivation elements, this might be a turn-off.
Final Verdict
"I Forged Them in Darkness, and They Buried Me in It" is a novel with a brilliant premise that unfortunately falls short in its execution. The pacing issues, inconsistent character development, and disappointing ending ultimately overshadow the initial promise. While the core concept might be enough to draw some readers in, be prepared for a potentially frustrating and unfulfilling experience. I'd recommend going in with tempered expectations.
