Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Reiko’s Manners – She’s Referred To As A Villainess, But Actually She’s Just Penniless
This novel presents an intriguing twist on the villainess trope, and I found myself surprisingly drawn into Reiko's world. It's a story that blends comedy, drama, and a touch of romance, all set within the confines of a prestigious academy. While it has its flaws, there's a certain charm that kept me reading.
First Impressions
The initial premise is what hooked me. Instead of a reincarnated soul taking over the villainess's body, we get the actual "villainess," Reiko, who is completely oblivious to the otome game scenario. Instead, she's just penniless and trying to navigate the complexities of high society. This subversion of expectations is refreshing and immediately sets the novel apart from others in the genre.
What Works Well
Many readers, myself included, enjoyed Reiko's character. She's not your typical strong, independent protagonist. Instead, she's a bit airheaded and naive, but possesses a natural elegance and kindness that draws people to her. Her manners, drilled into her by her grandmother, inadvertently give her an "I'm from a noble family" aura, which earns her acceptance among the wealthy students. The supporting cast, while somewhat archetypal, is also enjoyable, particularly Reiko's best friend, who adds a touch of yuri undertones to the story. I also appreciated that the world wasn't presented through rose-tinted glasses. The novel acknowledges the classism present in high society and portrays characters with both strengths and flaws. Reiko's passion for music, particularly the piano, also adds depth to her character and provides a potential avenue for future development.
Areas of Concern
While the premise is strong, some readers felt the author lost direction as the story progressed. The "otome game" aspect fades into the background, and the novel devolves into a more generic shoujo slice-of-life. I can see how this could be disappointing for readers who were drawn in by the initial concept. Some have also criticized the pacing, with excessive descriptions of mundane details and repetitive interactions. Reiko's naivety, while endearing to some, can also be frustrating, as she tends to forgive her abusers and give people too many chances. The quality of the translation has also been a point of contention, with some finding the use of honorifics like "Lord" and "Lady" in English unnatural and off-putting.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers felt that the plot goes haywire later on, with random events and unbelievable scenarios.
Final Verdict
Despite its flaws, "Reiko's Manners" offers a unique and enjoyable reading experience. The subversion of the villainess trope, the charming protagonist, and the exploration of class dynamics make it a worthwhile read. However, be aware that the story may lose focus as it progresses, and the translation may not be to everyone's taste. Ultimately, I'd recommend giving it a try if you're looking for a lighthearted and unconventional shoujo novel.
