Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Ryuugoroshi no Sugosuhibi
First Impressions
"Ryuugoroshi no Sugosuhibi" throws us into a classic isekai scenario: a normal Japanese student, Kousuke, suddenly finds himself in another world after quite literally falling from the sky. What makes this story stand out, at least initially, is its grounded protagonist. He's not a martial arts master or a cunning strategist, but a regular guy trying to navigate a bizarre and dangerous new reality. This premise immediately hooked me, promising a more relatable and realistic take on the genre.
What Works Well
I appreciated the slower pacing and the focus on Kousuke's adaptation to his new life. Many found it refreshing that he doesn't immediately embrace violence or power, but grapples with the moral implications of his newfound abilities. The comedy is also a strong point, providing lighthearted moments amidst the more serious themes. Kousuke's accidental dragon slaying is a fun and unique way to kick off the story, and the dynamic between him and the other characters, particularly Alice the witch, is genuinely engaging. It's nice to see a main character who isn't immediately surrounded by a dozen adoring girls, and the more realistic portrayal of relationships is a welcome change.
Areas of Concern
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
My biggest reservation, and the one that seems to be echoed by many readers, revolves around the character of Horun. The story initially sets her up as a potential love interest, but then subverts this expectation in a way that many find frustrating. She ends up falling for a noble who saves her from a relatively minor monster attack, despite Kousuke's repeated efforts to help and protect her, including a rather ridiculous stint disguised as a maid. This plot twist feels jarring and unearned, and it sours the overall experience for many. I can understand the desire to avoid clichés, but the execution here feels unnatural and undermines the initial promise of the story. Some even feel that the main reason they are reading this story has been destroyed.
Final Verdict
Despite its flaws, and particularly the controversial handling of Horun's romantic arc, "Ryuugoroshi no Sugosuhibi" is still an enjoyable read. The realistic protagonist, the comedic elements, and the intriguing world-building make it worth checking out, especially if you're looking for a more grounded and less formulaic isekai experience. Just be prepared for some potentially frustrating plot developments along the way. I'd give it a solid 3.5/5 – good, but with room for improvement.
