[I’m a Tomboy Mackerel After All] Just who the Hell Set up a Matchmaking Between me and a Mackerel!

[I’m a Tomboy Mackerel After All] Just who the Hell Set up a Matchmaking Between me and a Mackerel!

「私って男っぽくてサバなのよね」誰なんだよ俺との見合いにサバを呼んだやつは · Original Japanese title

Also known as: 「私って男っぽくてサバなのよね」誰なんだよ俺との見合いにサバを呼んだやつは

4.8 49 ratings
Completed japanese Web Novel

Our review

Reviewed by Kana

Who it's for, and whether it holds up.

Author profile

My Thoughts on [I’m a Tomboy Mackerel After All] Just who the Hell Set up a Matchmaking Between me and a Mackerel!

Okay, let's dive into this title. I mean, seriously, "[I’m a Tomboy Mackerel After All] Just who the Hell Set up a Matchmaking Between me and a Mackerel!" is certainly a mouthful, but it definitely grabbed my attention. A romance between a tomboy and, well, a mackerel? I had to see what this was all about.

First Impressions

Right off the bat, I was expecting something quirky and lighthearted, and that's precisely what I got. This oneshot doesn't waste any time throwing you into the absurdity of the situation. It's clear from the beginning that this isn't your typical fantasy romance, and that's part of its charm.

What Works Well

The humor is definitely the strongest point. It's the kind of silly, over-the-top humor that makes you chuckle, even if you're not entirely sure why. The pacing is also perfect for a oneshot. It gets straight to the point, develops the characters (as much as you can in a short story), and wraps everything up nicely without feeling rushed. It's a delightful little escape. The sweetness of the romance, despite the bizarre pairing, also adds to the overall appeal. There's a genuine heart beneath the comedic surface that makes the story surprisingly endearing. The slice-of-life elements are also well-executed, painting a vivid picture of the world and the characters' daily lives, even within the limited scope of a oneshot.

Areas of Concern

Honestly, it's hard to find major faults in a story that's so short and self-aware. If I had to nitpick, I'd say that the world-building could be a bit more fleshed out. But, given that it's a oneshot focused on comedy and romance, that's a minor issue. It does exactly what it sets out to do, and it does it well.

Final Verdict

If you're looking for a quick, funny, and heartwarming read that will leave you with a smile, "[I’m a Tomboy Mackerel After All] Just who the Hell Set up a Matchmaking Between me and a Mackerel!" is definitely worth checking out. It's a delightful breath of fresh air, perfect for a break between longer novels. Just don't expect a deep, complex plot – this is pure, unadulterated fun. I'd happily recommend it.

Synopsis

This is a short story of a Mackerel meeting with the Emperor. Rank 3rd in Syosetsu’s top 100 in Funny category as of 11/27/22. A good read for a break from long novels and chapters.

Details

Language
japanese
Type
Web Novel
Status
Completed
Chapters
Unknown
Original Publisher
syosetu

Genres & tags

Browse all reviews →