Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Except Me, Everyone Else Is the Protagonist
"Except Me, Everyone Else Is the Protagonist" is a wild ride through cultivation tropes, turned on their head with a healthy dose of self-aware humor. It's a story I found myself chuckling at constantly, and while it wasn't perfect, it left a lasting impression.
First Impressions
Initially, I was hooked by the sheer comedic energy. The premise itself is hilarious: a protagonist who's acutely aware that she's surrounded by other protagonists, each living out their own cultivation novel storylines. Our main character, Song Nanshi, is a clever and resourceful diviner, whose defining trait is her obsession with money. This immediately sets the stage for some laugh-out-loud moments as she navigates the world with her unique (and often morally flexible) approach to wealth acquisition.
What Works Well
The humor is definitely the strongest aspect of the novel. It's a satire of common cultivation tropes, and the author executes it brilliantly. The character dynamics are also a major highlight. Nanshi's interactions with the other "protagonists," her martial siblings, are genuinely heartwarming and hilarious. They form a found family that supports each other, even when Nanshi's money-grubbing antics get them into trouble. I particularly enjoyed how the author subverted expectations by making the male lead a sweet and devoted partner, a welcome change from the typical cold and aloof ML. The slow-burn romance between Nanshi and the ML felt natural and earned.
Areas of Concern
While I thoroughly enjoyed the novel, it wasn't without its flaws. The comedy, while initially refreshing, can become repetitive at times. The constant money gags, while funny at first, can overshadow the MC's other qualities and make her seem one-dimensional. Some found the romance writing to be a little off-putting, with some kissing scenes described in a way that felt forced.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers felt that the plot became repetitive, particularly with the recurring villain encounters. The dynamic between the youngest junior sister and her demon rabbit prince love interest also drew criticism, with some finding the constant (accidental) violence unfunny and even disturbing.
Final Verdict
Despite its flaws, "Except Me, Everyone Else Is the Protagonist" is a highly entertaining and enjoyable read. Its strengths lie in its clever humor, well-developed characters, and heartwarming found family dynamics. While the repetitive plot and occasional tonal inconsistencies might deter some readers, I believe the novel's overall charm and comedic brilliance make it a worthwhile experience. I'd recommend it to anyone looking for a lighthearted and satirical take on the cultivation genre.
