Reviewed by Kana
Who it's for, and whether it holds up.
My Thoughts on Even Though I was the Real Saint, I was Exiled—Which Means my Country is Over
This web novel presents a classic setup: a saintess, unappreciated and unfairly exiled, finds a new home and, presumably, revenge on those who wronged her. While the premise is enticing, the execution seems to be a mixed bag, leaving me with conflicted feelings.
First Impressions
Initially, I was drawn in by the potential for satisfying karmic justice. The idea of a kingdom collapsing after foolishly banishing its protector is undeniably appealing. However, I quickly realized that the story might not deliver on the depth I craved. The initial chapters feel rushed, with the exile happening too easily. I question the world-building where a prince can unilaterally banish someone so crucial to national security.
What Works Well
Despite my reservations, some aspects of the story shine. The simple, wish-fulfillment nature of the plot can be refreshing. There's a certain satisfaction in watching the protagonist find a better life and be appreciated for her abilities. The pacing, while quick, keeps the story moving, and some readers may find the lighthearted tone enjoyable. I can see how the comedic elements, though occasionally falling flat, could provide a pleasant diversion for those seeking a casual read.
Areas of Concern
My main issue lies with the protagonist's passivity and the somewhat nonsensical plot. She seems to accept her exile with little resistance, which, while perhaps realistic given the power dynamics, makes her appear strangely detached. The story relies heavily on convenient plot devices and characters who are either overwhelmingly good or cartoonishly evil. The lack of depth in both the protagonist and antagonists makes it difficult for me to fully invest in their journeys. I also feel that the premise of the country collapsing due to her absence isn't explored enough, and it's relegated to side chapters.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning
Some readers have pointed out that the initial setup involves the Crown Prince exiling the Saint based on the claims of his mistress, who is secretly plotting against the kingdom. This leads to immediate consequences, such as dragons attacking due to the barrier being down. However, the lack of repercussions for the Prince's actions is frustrating.
Final Verdict
"Even Though I was the Real Saint, I was Exiled—Which Means my Country is Over" has potential, but ultimately falls short of delivering a truly compelling narrative. It's a light, fluffy read that might appeal to those seeking simple wish-fulfillment. However, the weak world-building, passive protagonist, and lack of depth prevent it from being anything more than an okay time-killer. I would recommend this novel only to those who enjoy very simple and forgiving plots.
