My Brother, Who’s a Perfect Human Being, Has Stolen My Girlfriend and My Future, so I Went Back to the Past and Redo My Youth

In spring at the age of 26, after 10 years of dating since 2nd year of high school, I proposed to her. Her reply was that she would marry my younger brother instead of me. My younger brother, who’s a perfect human being and the complete opposite of me, has been having an affair with my girlfriend for the past 10 years. In despair over such a life-altering event, I threw the ring into the sea. Then somehow, time has brought me back to my 2nd year of high school, 10 years before I started dating her ! Having returned to the past, I will take revenge on my brother and my girlfriend who betrayed me, and start a new life !

Original Publisher

syosetu

Original Language

japanese

Type

Web Novel

## My Thoughts on *My Brother, Who’s a Perfect Human Being, Has Stolen My Girlfriend and My Future, so I Went Back to the Past and Redo My Youth* This title certainly grabs your attention, doesn't it? The premise – a betrayed man gets a second chance to rewrite his life – is undeniably appealing. However, after diving in, I found myself wrestling with some serious issues that ultimately dampened my enjoyment. ### First Impressions Initially, I was intrigued. The setup is classic revenge fare: a protagonist wronged by his seemingly perfect brother and unfaithful girlfriend. The time travel element adds a layer of complexity that I was eager to explore. But, as the story progressed, my excitement waned. ### What Works Well Honestly, finding positives was a struggle. The initial concept held promise, and I can see how some readers might be drawn to the wish-fulfillment aspect of a second chance. The potential for character growth is there, buried beneath layers of frustration. ### Areas of Concern My biggest issue lies with the protagonist, Kouki. His obsession with "winning" against his brother and parents feels childish and poorly executed. Instead of focusing on building a better future for himself, he's consumed by a need for their validation, a validation they seem unlikely to ever provide. This makes his actions feel aimless and, at times, downright illogical. The pacing is also a major problem. The tension between Kouki and his brother dissipates far too early, only to be resurrected with a plot twist that feels forced and uninspired. This inconsistent pacing undermines the story's momentum and makes it difficult to stay invested. Finally, the time travel mechanics feel arbitrary and poorly defined. The rules seem to change on a whim, leading to inconsistencies that undermine the story's internal logic. ### ⚠️ Spoiler Warning (This section contains potential spoilers based on reader reviews) Several readers expressed frustration with Kouki's decisions, particularly regarding his ex-girlfriend and his approach to revenge. His plan to bring his brother back after his family has already suffered seems counterproductive and driven by a need for a specific type of satisfaction that he may never achieve. The last straw for some was when the brother suddenly time travels and stabs him. ### Final Verdict Ultimately, *My Brother, Who’s a Perfect Human Being…* is a disappointing read. While the premise is intriguing, the execution falls short. The frustrating protagonist, inconsistent pacing, and poorly defined time travel mechanics make it difficult to recommend. I’d suggest approaching this one with caution.